In an EOR arrangement, the day-to-day management and evaluation of the employee remains entirely with you as the client. The EOR is the legal employer and handles contracts, payroll, and compliance, but has no visibility into daily work performance. How you organize performance management in practice depends on a clear division of responsibilities between you and the EOR. Below you will find answers to the most frequently asked questions on this topic.
Who is responsible for evaluating an EOR employee?
The substantive evaluation of an EOR employee is the responsibility of the client, not the EOR. The EOR acts as the legal employer and manages the administrative side of the employment relationship, but has no insight into daily activities, project results, or the employee’s performance. Performance reviews are therefore your responsibility as an organization.
In practice, this means that as the client you conduct performance reviews, set goals, and provide feedback. However, the EOR must be kept informed of significant developments in the employment relationship, such as a formal improvement plan or immediate dismissal. This is necessary because the EOR is legally responsible for complying with local employment law. Good collaboration and clear communication between you and the EOR are therefore essential.
Preferably document the division of responsibilities in writing in a service agreement or similar contract. This prevents ambiguity about who takes which step in performance-related matters.
How do you set goals and KPIs for an employee through an EOR?
Setting goals and KPIs for an EOR employee works essentially the same as for a direct employee. You as the client define the expectations, measurable objectives, and evaluation criteria. The EOR plays no substantive role in this. However, it is wise to take into account the employment law context of the country where the employee works when setting goals.
Practical steps for effective goal setting:
- Set goals at the start of the employment relationship or at the beginning of a new quarter or year.
- Use measurable criteria, such as revenue targets, project milestones, customer satisfaction scores, or deadlines.
- Document the agreements in writing and share them with the employee.
- Schedule regular check-ins to discuss progress, especially with remote employees in a different time zone.
- Inform the EOR if goals are adjusted in a way that affects the contract, such as a change in role or salary adjustment.
Keep in mind that some countries have specific rules about what an employer may require of an employee. When in doubt, consult with the EOR about the local context before setting goals that may have legal implications.
What happens if an EOR employee underperforms?
If an EOR employee underperforms, you as the client are responsible for initiating an improvement plan. The EOR supports this process by ensuring that all steps comply with the local employment law requirements of the country where the employee works. Without that alignment, you risk an improvement plan being legally challenged later.
An improvement plan for an EOR employee typically proceeds as follows:
- Document the performance issues with concrete examples, data, and previous feedback moments.
- Discuss the situation with the EOR before taking formal steps. The EOR is familiar with local rules around improvement plans, warnings, and documentation requirements.
- Draw up a formal improvement plan, also known as a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP), with clear goals, a timeline, and consequences.
- Schedule regular evaluation moments during the process and document the outcomes in writing.
- Keep the EOR informed of progress, so the EOR can provide timely legal advice if dismissal becomes a possibility.
The requirements for a valid improvement plan vary significantly by country. In some countries, an extensively documented process is legally required before dismissal is possible. In other countries, the rules are more flexible. The EOR is your most important guide in this regard.
Can an EOR employee be dismissed based on performance?
Yes, an EOR employee can be dismissed based on insufficient performance, but the procedure varies by country and must always go through the EOR as the legal employer. You as the client cannot independently dismiss an EOR employee. You instruct the EOR to terminate the employment relationship, after which the EOR follows the local dismissal procedure.
What you need to know about dismissal with an EOR:
- The EOR assesses whether the dismissal is legally defensible based on local legislation.
- In many countries, strict requirements apply, such as a demonstrable improvement plan, written warnings, and a notice period.
- The EOR calculates and pays any severance payments, which are then reimbursed to the EOR by you.
- Dismissal without proper documentation or without following the correct procedure can lead to legal claims, even if the client and EOR are based in different countries.
Always ensure that you have completed an improvement plan and documented it thoroughly before requesting the EOR to terminate the employment relationship. This protects both you and the EOR from legal risks.
Which tools and systems work well for EOR performance management?
For EOR performance management, tools work best when they are cloud-based, accessible to teams in multiple countries, and independent of the EOR’s HR systems. Because the EOR manages payroll and contracts in its own systems, you as the client need a separate system for the substantive management and evaluation of employees.
Popular categories and examples:
- Performance management software: Platforms such as Lattice, 15Five, or Leapsome offer features for goal setting, continuous feedback, and formal review cycles.
- Project management tools: Tools such as Asana, Monday.com, or Notion help with recording tasks, progress, and results, which can serve as a basis for performance discussions.
- Communication platforms: Regular one-on-ones via Microsoft Teams or Zoom, combined with structured agendas, keep the connection with remote EOR employees strong.
- Document storage: Always document reviews, improvement plans, and feedback conversations in writing in a shared system such as Google Drive or SharePoint.
Choose tools that are also usable for employees abroad and ensure that the EOR has access to relevant documents when legal steps are required.
What are the biggest pitfalls in performance management through an EOR?
The biggest pitfall in performance management through an EOR is underestimating the legal complexity per country. Clients often assume that their own HR processes and dismissal procedures are universally applicable, but local employment law can differ significantly. This leads to situations where an improvement plan or dismissal turns out to be legally untenable after the fact.
Other common mistakes:
- Poor documentation: Verbally given feedback or informal warnings are insufficient as legal evidence in many countries when it comes to dismissal.
- Late communication with the EOR: Clients sometimes wait too long to inform the EOR about performance issues, leaving the EOR insufficient time to guide the process correctly from a legal perspective.
- No clear division of responsibilities: Ambiguity about who handles what leads to delays and mistakes when swift action is required.
- Cultural blind spots: Giving and receiving feedback varies greatly across cultures. What is considered direct and constructive feedback in one country may be perceived as confrontational or disrespectful in another.
- No alignment on contract changes: If a role changes, goals are adjusted, or a salary increase follows a positive review, the EOR must always be informed because this affects the contract.
Those who avoid these pitfalls build a performance management process that is both effective and legally sound, even across borders.
How Eastwing helps with performance management through an EOR
Eastwing helps organizations that employ international staff or work through an EOR to properly structure HR processes. We understand the complexity of working with employees in multiple countries and think along with you about how to organize performance management in a practical and legally correct way.
What we do for you:
- We help you establish a clear division of responsibilities between you as the client and the EOR.
- We advise on the right documentation for improvement plans and performance reviews.
- We identify cultural and legal points of attention per country, so you avoid unnecessary risks.
- We support you in choosing tools and processes that suit an international team.
Would you like to know how to properly handle performance management through an EOR for your situation? Get in touch and we will be happy to think along with you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to involve the EOR in every performance review I conduct with an employee?
No, you do not need to involve the EOR in every performance review. Regular appraisal meetings, check-ins, and feedback sessions you conduct independently as the client. You do need to inform the EOR as soon as formal steps with legal consequences are involved, such as an official improvement plan (PIP), a written warning, or a possible termination of the employment relationship. As a rule of thumb: the greater the legal impact, the sooner you inform the EOR.
How do I deal with an EOR employee in a country whose employment law I am not familiar with?
This is exactly the situation an EOR is designed for. Consult your EOR proactively before setting up or adjusting HR processes for employees in a specific country. The EOR is familiar with local rules regarding working hours, review cycles, documentation requirements, and dismissal procedures. When onboarding a new employee, immediately request a brief overview of the relevant local employment law considerations, so you can set up performance management correctly from the start.
What if an EOR employee disagrees with their performance review?
If an employee objects to a review, it is important that you have documented, concrete examples to support your assessment. Have an open conversation and document the outcome in writing. Inform the EOR if the conflict escalates or takes on a legal dimension, such as a formal complaint or threat of legal action. In some countries, employees have statutory rights to object to reviews, and the EOR can advise you on how to handle this correctly.
Can I promote an EOR employee or change their role based on a positive review?
Yes, that is possible, but a change of role or promotion always has consequences for the contract managed by the EOR. Inform the EOR in a timely manner about the desired change, so they can update the contract and verify whether the new role or salary complies with local laws and regulations, such as minimum wage requirements or collective bargaining agreements. Only communicate the change officially to the employee after the EOR has confirmed the contractual adjustments.
How do I keep performance management manageable when I have multiple EOR employees in different countries?
Use one central performance management system, such as Lattice or 15Five, for all employees regardless of their location. Set up a standardized review cycle, but allow room for country-specific adjustments in documentation and procedure. Create a brief internal overview per country of the legal considerations provided by the EOR, so your team leaders always know which steps they can and cannot take independently. Having a dedicated point of contact at the EOR per region or country also helps to act quickly when needed.
What is the difference between an informal warning and a formal warning for an EOR employee?
An informal warning is a verbal or written feedback moment without legal status, intended to make the employee aware of a performance issue. A formal warning is an official document that forms part of a legal process and in many countries is a mandatory step before dismissal. The distinction is crucial: informal warnings are insufficient evidence in a dismissal procedure in most countries. Always discuss with the EOR when you need to move from informal to formal, so your documentation is legally watertight.
How do I ensure that cultural differences do not undermine my performance reviews?
Research the communication culture of the country where your employee works in advance. In some cultures, direct criticism is uncommon and feedback is better received when framed indirectly or positively, while employees from other cultures specifically need explicit and structured feedback. Ask your EOR or a local HR advisor for a brief cultural overview during the onboarding of a new employee. Also use structured evaluation forms with concrete, measurable criteria, so the review remains as objective as possible regardless of cultural expectations.